Employee engagement strategies that work

Your employees’ experience and job satisfaction is shaped by your company’s culture, work environment, technology company strategy, products and services, and even the external macroeconomic environment. To improve it, you need an employee engagement strategy, and the backbone of that strategy must be listening.

We’ve known about the impact of engaged employees on business performance for a long time.  Quite simply, when you engage employees, they are more focused on their role, their colleagues and your customers.

We’ve all met engaged employees – either as colleagues or customers – and been delighted by the experience.

Equally, we’ve all encountered disengaged employees, and been frustrated and dissatisfied with the experience.

In the current economic downturn, it’s those organizations that maximize employee engagement and the wider employee experience, and root out the causes of employee disengagement, that will survive and be in a position to thrive when the economy turns around.

Budgets and resources are constrained. People at all levels, from senior leaders through to frontline managers and even employees themselves are disproportionately investing time and energy into enhancing employee experiences to drive employee engagement and business performance.

In short, what’s needed is an effective employee engagement strategy.

Transform your employee engagement with XM for People’s Teams

What are the best employee engagement strategies for understanding & enhancing engagement levels?

Traditionally, for many organizations, the strategy to increase employee engagement revolved solely around the annual employee engagement survey.  Typically, this was a heavy effort, needing weeks or even months of survey design, pre-survey communications, reporting, and, if there was any interest and energy left at the end, some action.

The annual employee engagement survey was frustrating – too infrequent, too slow, and often failing to drive engagement levels.

One study found that only 44% of employees have seen positive changes as a result of previous employee surveys, and just 42% have been given the opportunity to discuss last year’s survey results.

In short, the annual engagement survey approach became stagnant.

Now, with the development of technology and AI, and Experience Management recognized as a discipline, strategies for improving employee engagement have evolved beyond the annual survey – and even beyond engagement itself.

Employee Engagement vs. Employee Experience

Before we explore current employee listening approaches, let’s understand the difference between employee engagement and employee experience:

 Employee experience

This is the sum of all experiences a person has throughout their relationship with an organization – before, during and after.  Employee engagement is one of the critical outcomes that’s a product of employee experience, and one of the metrics an organization should track to monitor its health.

Employee engagement

Employee engagement has been the mainstay of employee listening programs for decades. It has become a standard of employee listening because it has consistently been proven to be a predictor of employee and business success.

Employee engagement is more precisely defined as the combination of three factors:

1. Recommend:  Advocacy, or likelihood to recommend the organization as a place to work.

2. Motivate: The willingness to give discretionary effort, or go above and beyond.

3. Personal accomplishment: Feeling that your work gives you a sense of accomplishment is key to having a sense of workplace purpose.

Listen across the whole employee lifecycle for improved employee engagement

Modern experience management programs that use AI and machine learning now let organizations capture feedback from employees at any time, and from anywhere, across the employee lifecycle:

How the best employee engagement strategies keep employees engaged

Using the latest technology and AI across the above lifecycle stages, you’ll be able to quickly understand and identify insights from employees – whether they have job satisfaction or not.

Techniques used to support the measurement, analysis and action of employee feedback include:

1.    In-the-moment listening

Rather than waiting for infrequent, scheduled surveys, employees can provide real-time feedback as they are having the experience.  For example, when an employee uses an online tool, its use triggers a short, simple survey.

2.   In-the-moment action

When feedback can be provided in real time, experience gaps can be identified quicker and actions can be taken to close those gaps almost instantaneously.  For example, when a potential candidate reviews the job spec on an online careers page for a critical, hard-to-fill role, a site intercept survey could be triggered after one minute to ask what more information the person requires.  This may help organizations increase their candidate pool and reduce time to hire.

3.   Multi-rater feedback / 360° (or 180°) feedback

Multiple points of view – from peers, managers, direct reports – can be transformational in helping employees gain both broad and deep insights into their behavior and improve their performance and development opportunities.

4.   Unstructured data

Undoubtedly surveys can provide robust data from across the organization, but there is a risk of survey fatigue.  A wealth of untapped information already sits in Yammer, Slack channels, social media sites and the conversations with internal service centers – the necessary data and insight may already exist.

AI-driven analysis of unstructured data can quickly identify at scale the issues employees are raising, their feelings, and the impact these are having on their engagement and wider experience.  Text and conversational analytics are the next frontier in employee listening and where organizations are increasingly turning to bolster their employee listening programs.

 5. Manager-led surveys

With greater EX maturity comes the ability of local leaders and managers to engage more effectively with their employees using employee feedback.  Organizations are using survey tools to empower local managers and leaders to capture frontline experience when they need to, on topics relevant to their team, but within the guardrails of curated surveys.  Used on a common platform, HR and executive teams can also continuously monitor organization-wide sentiment.

 6. Action planning with ideas boards

Local ownership extends beyond just the survey and insights, to include action planning.  Ideas boards – where teams add ideas anonymously and up-vote each other’s ideas – can be used to crowdsource ideas about what exactly leaders could do to improve employee engagement.  After collection, a manager will have a set of potential solutions for their focus areas on which they can act.

 7. Data connection

While collecting feedback from different points of the employee lifecycle can be incredibly powerful, insights can be amplified when these data are combined into a single dataset.

For example, connecting onboarding feedback with engagement and pulse survey data can provide rich insights into the onboarding practices, company culture and processes that contribute to ongoing high levels of engagement (or disengagement and turnover).

When you connect exit survey data with engagement and pulse data you gain a richer picture of leavers – especially regretted leavers who exit for a competitor or similar role. Your engagement survey then becomes an early warning system of employees who share a similar profile to actual regretted leavers.

And when you go a step further by connecting EX feedback with customer or consumer feedback (CX), you’ll understand not only how employee engagement is correlated with the customer experience, but how the drivers of EX impact on CX.  For example, you’ll understand which areas of the employee experience most influence customers’ purchasing decisions, and are most worth investing in.  These insights enable organizations to invest in the areas of their employee experience because they impact business performance.

What does a modern engagement survey deliver?

Don’t think that experience management and advances in technology, analytics and AI, signal the end of engagement and pulse surveys – they don’t. At the core of a modern employee listening program remains an all-employee holistic measure of  ‘What’s it like to work here?’

So, why do we recommend that you keep engagement surveys at the heart of your employee experience listening program?

You’ll understand the drivers of engagement

Employee engagement levels do not remain static, so the relative importance of the drivers of employee engagement will change over time due to both internal and external factors.

Our EX Global Trends Report 2023 found the top drivers to be:

1. Instilling confidence you are running a successful ship
2. Employees, previously operating at surge levels for years, are now reclaiming boundaries
3. Bad processes and inefficient systems are fueling employee burnout
4. Being employed isn’t just about having a job – it’s a part of a person’s value system

You’ll get a holistic view

An all-employee survey, measuring the whole employee experience, remains your main opportunity to understand that experience across all the organization. You’ll be able to identify the priority areas to focus on across organizational levels, and zoom into key employee groups.

Survey with a lighter touch

Gone are the days when annual engagement surveys contained 60 or 70 items, as every business function wanted to ‘add their questions’. Because of lifecycle surveys, there is less pressure for the annual engagement survey to be lengthy and, consequently, the annual surveys can be lighter, more focused and more relevant to employees.

You’ll get enhanced metrics

Ongoing research has refined the KPIs and drivers of the employee experience, and the best way to measure these succinctly.

It’s quick to deploy

Technology makes it easier than ever to set up surveys quickly and integrate the feedback with existing human resources systems to ensure the accuracy of the organizational and personal data.  Dashboard reports are available immediately so that there’s no gap between the Engagement survey closing and feedback distribution.

Your dashboards can be role-based

Whether you’re a frontline manager wanting to know how engaged your team is and where you need to focus, or a senior leader wanting to understand differences in engagement levels and the drivers of engagement across business areas and key populations, you can easily configure dashboards so that relevant actionable insight is put into the hands of people who can use it to move quickly from insight to action.

 Employees can get involved in actions

With collaborative action planning there are more opportunities for employees to be involved: discussing results, agreeing priorities and supporting actions.  The traditional criticism that engagement surveys generate lots of activity and no action is no longer valid.

What’s included in a modern all-employee experience engagement survey?

Key performance indicators (KPIs)

Employee engagement remains the definitive employee measurement, but it is now one of a number of critical outcomes that make up Employee Experience.

Other KPIs include:

• Intent to Stay
• Experience vs Expectations
• Wellbeing
• Inclusion

Drivers of employee experience

Drivers are the topics that influence the KPIs. Understanding the drivers, and the relative importance of each driver to the KPIs, indicates the priorities for focus from group level through to front-line team level.  In fact, understanding the drivers of employee experience is arguably more important than measuring the KPIs.

This foundation can be further configured so that each organization adapts and configures this model to the specific needs and realities of their organization.

Pulse surveys

With today’s rapidly shifting business priorities, organizations are supplementing annual baseline engagement surveys with more frequent pulse surveys. These measure the KPIs continuously, help stay on top of the most critical EX drivers and further explore priorities.

The right cadence

How often pulse surveys get sent out will depend on the capability and capacity of your organization to act on the feedback.

Research recommends a quarterly rhythm of an annual engagement survey and three quarterly pulses – the sweet spot for employee expectations to give feedback and for managers and teams to give, discuss and act on feedback.